Carlos Saura/Antonio Gades' "Carmen" (1983).... ... is the most sensual of all and truly Spanish
Passionate, dramatic, riveting as Flamenco itself, the film is simply amazing. It is set on the immortal Bizet's music. The original music is written and performed by one of the greatest classical guitarists, leading proponent of the Modern Flamenco style, Paco de Lucia who plays a musician with the same name. Legendary Flamenco dancer and choreographer Antonio Gades co/wrote the script and choreographed this fabulous version of the celebrated Georges Bizet/Prosper Mérimée novella/opera. He plays a main character Antonio, the famous dancer/choreographer who works on retelling the story of Carmen in the Flamenco style that combines dances with singing and rhythmic hand clapping and has a highly charged level of dynamics that appeals enormously to the viewers.
Brilliant and graceful Cristina Hoyos whose technical excellence matches the elegant artistry of her dancing shines in the supporting role. Hoyos had been the first dancer in Gades' company for twenty years (1968-1988) and she was the protagonist of three films that Carlos Saura made of Gades' three great shows: "Bodas de Sangre" (1978), "Carmen" (1983) and "El Amor Brujo" (1985). Gorgeous Laura del Sol is a young dancer named Carmen in whom Antony sees from the first sight another Carmen, who was immortalized by two Frenchmen, the writer Prosper Mérimée in his most famous novella written in 1846 that had inspired George Bizet's world famous Opéra-Comique version from 1875.
As in the opera and in the novella, Carmen in Saura's film is desirable and deadly, the ultimate femme fatale who has to be free above anything else. She could not tolerate the possessive love of any man and would prefer death to submission. There some 50 movie adaptations of the story and the opera to the screen, and as different as they are, they all have in common the only possible tragic end. Saura/Gades' film is unique as the most sensual of all and truly Spanish. I fell in love with it from the first time I saw it over twenty years ago and it is as special and beautiful today as it was back then. Highly recommended.
Rosabel- 12-11-2007
Coincidentally, Galina, I've seen the film for the first time about 20 years ago, too, and rewatched it about 2 months ago, with the same delight and admiration I felt the first time. The film hasn't aged at all, and I agree with every word of your review.
A friend sent me an excellent TV documentary about Carlos Saura, and I have to confess my amazement - "Carmen" is his only film I know, but Saura is in fact much more important to (not only Spanish) film history than I guessed; I had no idea about his pre-war black-and-white films, the films he made in the Franco era, or that he was also a very inspired photographer as well as draughtsman (there were some of his story boards in the docu). I wish there were more of his films on DVD.
Galina- 12-11-2007
Coincidentally, Galina, I've seen the film for the first time about 20 years ago, too, and rewatched it about 2 months ago, with the same delight and admiration I felt the first time. The film hasn't aged at all, and I agree with every word of your review.
A friend sent me an excellent TV documentary about Carlos Saura, and I have to confess my amazement - "Carmen" is his only film I know, but Saura is in fact much more important to (not only Spanish) film history than I guessed; I had no idea about his pre-war black-and-white films, the films he made in the Franco era, or that he was also a very inspired photographer as well as draughtsman (there were some of his story boards in the docu). I wish there were more of his films on DVD.
Hello Dear Rosochka-Laurochka
It is great to be again among the friends. :)
I somehow knew that you would respond to my post because I remember you have named Carmen as one of your favorite movies. It is one of ageless films, and time has no power over it. It took about 25 years to transfer it on DVD but finally it is available. As a matter of fact, the whole Flamenco trilogy was released by Eclipse Series 6:Carlos Saura's Flamenco Trilogy (Blood Wedding / Carmen / El Amor Brujo) (Criterion Collection): http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000TXNDVG/ref=cm_rna_own_review_prod
I am going to rent the rest of the trilogy from Netflix where they are available. Besides "Carmen", I saw his Oscar nominated film "Tango" which I love, and Outrage! (1993), completely different in style, brutal, dark, and violent revenge tragedy with pre-Hollywood Antonio Banderas and Francesca Neri. "Outrage" is a passionate film but I don’t think I'd want to see it again.
Thanks for the information about Saura. I know that he's been making films for long time and is one of the most admired figures in Spanish cinema. I have not had chance to see his old movies. Don Luis Bunuel names Saura his favorite director ever and it is the best praise to any director.
How are you, Laurochka? :)
bunnygloves- 12-11-2007
While I'm wholly unfamiliar with this film, I felt I must reply because I adore Bizet and his Carmen remains one of my favorite operas - in fact, I just saw it last month at the New York City Opera, and am seeing it yet again in February at the Metropolitan Opera when Franco Zeffirelli is directing it!
I also wanted to use this as a chance to plug one of 2007's best films - Mark Dornford-May's U-Carmen e-Khayelitsha, which is an amazing modern adaptation of the opera, set in a small African township and sung entirely in Xhosa!
The modernization works beautifully, and serves to make the opera that much more poignant. Get the DVD if you can!
Galina- 12-11-2007
Thank you for recommendation: While I'm wholly unfamiliar with this film, I felt I must reply because I adore Bizet and his Carmen remains one of my favorite operas - in fact, I just saw it last month at the New York City Opera, and am seeing it yet again in February at the Metropolitan Opera when Franco Zeffirelli is directing it!
I also wanted to use this as a chance to plug one of 2007's best films - Mark Dornford-May's U-Carmen e-Khayelitsha, which is an amazing modern adaptation of the opera, set in a small African township and sung entirely in Xhosa!
The modernization works beautifully, and serves to make the opera that much more poignant. Get the DVD if you can!
I've added "U-Carmen e-Khayelitsha" to my Netflix Q and I will move it up based on your recommendation and the viewers comments on the movie's Netflix site. I, in turn, highly recommend that you watch Saura's "Carmen". It is a unique watching experience, some magic blend of opera's arias, dramatic story, and Flamenco dancing. Right now I am awaiting from Netflix my MOST favorite version of "Carmen" which is Bizet-Shchedrin: Carmen Suite Ballet . It was written in 1973 by the Soviet Composer Rodion Shchedrin who used Bize't music from the Opera and his others few works. Shchedrin composed the ballet for his wife, the world famous, and perhaps the greatest dancer of the 20th Century (I truly mean it), Maya Plisetskaya. To dance Carmen had been Maya's dream for many years. She IS Carmen. She is genius. There is one scene in the ballet where Carmen sits on the chair watching bull-fighting. She just sits, but you won't see anyone else in the scene with many characters. I can't wait to receive the DVD.
Rosabel- 12-13-2007
Hello Galina dearest:
due to a little bunch of reasons I've been quite an irregular poster here during the last 1½ months (which hopefully will change back to normal again soon), so when I came back here yesterday I was surprised and very pleased to find you a bit more present than before , and I only just now read your imdb adventures - I'm almost inclinded to also hug that mala bestia that chased you away :) because this here is the much more friendly place ... although, reading your "We, the deleted" thread gave me a lot to think about ... that's how the world will work in the future, I guess?
Well, back to Saura: from the docu I mentioned it seems that "Carmen" is the best of his dance films, his most compelling, but let me hear how the others appeal to you, they are not yet available over here, don't know if they ever will be. I'd be especially curious to see the Tango film, since I love this Argentinian music.
Rosabel- 12-13-2007
I also wanted to use this as a chance to plug one of 2007's best films - Mark Dornford-May's U-Carmen e-Khayelitsha, which is an amazing modern adaptation of the opera, set in a small African township and sung entirely in Xhosa!
The modernization works beautifully, and serves to make the opera that much more poignant. Get the DVD if you can!
Hadn't heard of it, so thanks for the tip, bunny, and if anybody else is curious, here are the details:
http://imdb.com/title/tt0445776/
Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.